Xperia X high battery consumption in Kvarken 4.1.0.24

[jojomen]

REPRODUCIBILITY (% or how often): Always
BUILD ID = OS VERSION (Settings > About product): 4.1.0.24
HARDWARE (XA2, Xperia 10…): Xperia X
UI LANGUAGE: Swedish
REGRESSION: (compared to previous public release: Yes, No, ?): Yes

DESCRIPTION:

I experience higher power consumption since updating from 4.0. There have been reports connecting this to WLAN use, but that is not the issue here, as far as I can tell.

I have tested as below to see if I can find a culprit app, to no avail. It looks more as an OS problem.

Please advice if there is anything more I should test.

PRECONDITIONS:

In order to provide consistent data, I have

• Charged to 80%
• Switched off all radios (mobile, WLAN, BT) and GPS
• Powered off the device
• Powered on the device

STEPS TO REPRODUCE:

1. Setup as above
2. Start zero or more apps
3. Show home screen
4. Leave device idle for 10+ hours

EXPECTED RESULT:

A drop in battery around 0.3%/h with four apps idle. Several days of light device use on a charge.

ACTUAL RESULT:

Apps running         Discharge
-----------------          -------------
None                       <0.2%/h        
Settings                    0.4%/h
Calendar                    0.4%/h
Four apps                  >1.4%/h

The four apps were Settings, Calendar, Situations and Pure Maps.

ADDITIONAL INFORMATION:

• Under Koli 4.0.1 with these four apps “running” (i.e. idle), I could expect about the same discharge rate as Kvarken 4.1.0.24 shows with no apps at all.
• It seems more power is consumed when I actually use the apps, in comparison with Koli 4.0.1, but that is hard to measure. I get 0.5-2 days of use from a charge now.
• It seems apps are slower to start and more sluggish to use, in comparison with Koli 4.0.1, which also hard to measure.

POSSIBLY RELATED:

[release notes] Kvarken 4.1.0

Hi all I gave my Xperia X installed with SFOS 4.1 to my girlfriend some days ago. She just complained to me about the heat and the quick battery drain. I don’t remember having those issues while I was using this phone as a daily driver (from 2.x to 4.0). Are these known issues of SFOS 4.1 on Xperia X ? What could we do to help find the root cause ? Cheers, Samuel

[4.1.0.23] Heavy power drain due to connected WLAN

Continuing the discussion from [release notes] Kvarken 4.1.0: As reported (and confirmed by other) my X suffers from a heavy power drain. I tested a lot and it is absolutely only happening when WLAN is connected. It is a more or less plain vanilla device (storeman, sfos-upgrade, harbour-defender) for testing. Upgraded from 3.3 up to 4.1. One mail account, set to sync manual. Tested with all radio on, only network, network and cell data, WLAN enabled (but not connected) and other combinatio…

(But please note that my testing is with WLAN off.)

[paulvt]

For me, this has been going for a few releases now. Using the original top tool (before the now more useless top got merged in), it was clear that systemd-logind was using the most CPU time, followed by voicecall-ui if I had been calling.

[nephros]

systemdatascope (or rather collectd) has recently gained per-process monitoring.

I suggest adding all of the suspected processes to this and leave it collecting for some time.

Then plot it with systemdatascope.

Note that it scaled graphs down to ‘millipercent’ so be sure to read them correctly.

Also note that you may want to use collectd’s ProcessMatch rather that Process directive for apps that apeear more than once in ps (like all the invoker-started apps).

[jojomen]

I tried monitoring my top-used apps one by one, but didn’t get very far. It looked like there was suspiciously little sleeping going on, though.

Then, after receiving some updates, things now look pretty normal powerwise since several days. App change logs show that Battery Buddy got a relevant update - an app I had forgotten about, because I don’t start or interact with it. (There’s a background service that starts automatically.)

So, battery consumption is good again and I think I know why. Big thanks to @direc85 for your work on Battery Buddy!

@paulvt are you still experiencing high drain?

[paulvt]

Sometimes. But it is also in part due to community apps not sleeping very well.
Still, I find the systemd-logind at the top of the list in CPU time suspicious. I haven’t gotten around to investigating it yet though.

[paulvt]

More also in this (more recent) bug report: Process systemd-logind constant 3-7%CPU usage, scanning camera and audio devices