Have the same Problem and it is anoying as hell! It happens not only once a day, that all apps or at least all android apps are closed while phone is laying arround. No Android, no Nextcloud talk messages are ariving anymore. You only get notice of it if you get a call, asking for response
4.2.0.21 does not make anything better!
Has someone reported this via zendesk? Maybe none of the responsible at Jolla is reading hereā¦
I find the result quite dramatic (positively) especially for android apps, and its seems to resist in time and reboots. 1GB swap is probably overkill though.
Thanks for sharing your experiences! Does the entry for the /swapfile really work for you on a reboot? Somehow in my case the swapfile does not get mounted on a XA2. The only difference is that I made the swap on /home/swapfile instead directly in root. Does this matter somehow?
I can confirm that komoot is crashing after some minutes of usage. No other apps open or in background at this time. This is valid for all other navigation apps I am using - OSM and Here. I am on a XA2 and discovered this behavior with the latest version of Sailfish. Can not remember seeing this before.
Ah OK. I checked if the swapfile in the root directory gets automounted and it works.
Here are the two lines in the fstab: /home/swapfile none swap defaults 0 0 doesnāt work /swapfile none swap defaults 0 0 works
After some testing with an additional swapfile I can say that the problem still exist. Navigation Apps still crashing after some minutes. I can see that swap is growing after start but with a maximum of 150MB. Memory used is growing from 1,3GB in idle without any apps to ~1,8GB then crashing. How much memory do your devices consume after start without any other apps?
That is really not a good metric with Linux kernels which follow the āfree RAM is wasted RAMā philosophy. On a properly working system you could see 99% used memory all the time and nothing crashing.
The whole thing is made even more complicated on SFOS where the native side and the Android side use different technologies for dealing with low memory situations - and the technologies used differ from device to device and release to release.
Thanks for the hints. By used memory I meant the active memory. There was a bunch of cached and buffered memory too so that free memory was something round 40MB before crash. After studying the links in your post I understand the problem better.
Tested this on XZ2c, and definitely improves thingsā¦ Infortunately, my remaining system memory is barely over 1g as is. Maybe will test 750 or somethingā¦
I recently acquired a SanDisk Extreme Pro 64GB memory card. Specs says it puts out 170 MB/s read and 90 MB/s write. On my Xperia 10 II I disabled system swap and enabled swapfile on sd only. I also messed with swappiness to test things out. 6 android apps and 4 system. Device is noticeably slower when switching apps but overall very stable. Once app is switched it acts normal. I need to test things some more but it seems that sd can be a replacment for internal swap. Anyway, I would like to test performance with both swaps equal size (internal and sd) mounted with equal priorities. In theory this should ads up speed of sd and internal, or am I wrong?
For swappiness, Iād try standard sysctl approach; for some reason thereās no sysctl.conf on Sailfish, but you can create file ā letās name it local-swappiness.conf in /etc/sysctl.d and put
vm.swappiness = 90
(whatever value you see fitting) in there. Name is irrelevant, I used local- prefix to avoid potential conflicts, just remember the .conf extension is needed.
Can you show, how do you try to set swap priority?
Will this also work with swap settings as decribed below?:
swapoff /dev/zram0
swapon -p 2 /run/media/defaultuser/6239-3830/swap
swapon -p 2 /dev/zram0
This gives me two equal swap spaces with equal priorities and this indeed works nice, 6 android and 6 system apps were around full ram and 75% of swap and everything worked stable. I previously tried giving minus somethings priority value but it didnāt work for unknown reason, giving it prios above 1 works.
It just would be nice to have this on startup rather than typing this into terminal each time I reboot
If nobody wants to fix me with right solution for changing swap settings automaticly maybe there is one person which can point me into right direction? Is there a place where I can put executable script?
What is the full path of swapon & swapoff?