SF browser: youtube playback stopped working since a few days

REPRODUCIBILITY: 100%
OS VERSION: 4.5.0.15 & 5.0.0.62
HARDWARE: Sony Xperia 10 III
UI LANGUAGE: German
REGRESSION:

DESCRIPTION: videos in sailfish-browser on platform youtube are shown but playback only works for a fraction of a second

PRECONDITIONS: none

STEPS TO REPRODUCE:

  • open sailfish-browser
  • goto youtube.com
  • select any video you want
  • press play button
    ===================

EXPECTED RESULT: video playback starts an goes on

ACTUAL RESULT: almost nothing happens

MODIFICATIONS: patchmanager with stock emoji keyboard

ADDITIONAL INFORMATION: none

7 Likes

i have this.

not in every yt vid, but certainly in most.

yepp, they seem to change something. Even the very good native App Microtube doesn’t play older Videos from Youtube.

Time to get independent.

Internal bug filed to check is we can do something in the Browser.
Thank you for reporting.

We noticed that the YT videos start working if you switch the browser to the desktop mode.
In other words, on m.youtube.com the playback is broken.

7 Likes

Cool, I was thinking I should report this problem, but it’s already been done.
Not only do videos play for 1 second and stop (repeatedly when play is pressed), when they do finally play, the browser crashes back to its cover, this happens quite regularly whether using YT or not. Despite all the hard work by Piggz, I still find the browser largely unusable for everyday use. 10 years on, still nothing really works with any aplomb, it’s extremely disappointing.

Everyone around me, pulls out their Android or iPhone and gets on with seeing what they need to see, but nooooo, not “Selfish Sailfish”, it’s all a bit crashy, then it’s frozen, now it “needs a reboot” bullshit…it’s all worn a bit thin for me I’m afraid, clearly nobody in management gives a toss unless it is about company funding, well I guess you have to keep them skiing holidays and new cars coming eh boss?, it’s a poor show and has been for too long.
{{{SIGH}}}

1 Like

Trying to improve over here [ua] Try to improve youtube.com playback. JB#63335 by rainemak · Pull Request #1115 · sailfishos/sailfish-browser · GitHub

8 Likes

I hope this can help: the issue is not happening with youtube embedded videos in other sites (e.g. kickstarter, sony, ecc)

1 Like

The fix is OTA deployed for ESR91. Upon the next update trigger you should have it.

4 Likes

The OTA fix works well on my XA2. Thank you!

On a related note, I’ve noticed 1080p being automatically selected sooner and more frequently. I don’t let YouTube sites set cookies, so there are no saved settings. This auto-detection starts from scratch for every YouTube video played on my device in the native browser.

By the way, no saved cookies means no logging in, no personalized recommendations, no cookie popups, and less tracking. I do prefer it that way.

Just out of curiosity, have you tried to use for example firefox with AAS? Does that work any better compared to native browser? Lets hope the next ESR update will come sooner rather than later

A few days ago, I did try what you’ve said. Cutting a long story short, I did not succeed.

I was hit with too many errors/nothing found or messages saying “not available for your device”, looked in Aurora Store and F-Droid. I don’t care for grabbing any APK gleaned via a Google search either.

I haven’t spent much time on finding an alternative/workaround.

1 Like

I did exactly one of the things I said I don’t care for doing. Downloaded a Firefox APK from a Google search (Firefox v 137.0.2), installed it, ran it and it works ok so far…

Videos in YouTube play back just fine, there seems to be a little bit of frame drop/lipsync, even at 360p, but all have been watchable, including using captions. Videos full screen correctly without fuss, so far, so good.

I also installed UblockOrigin plugin for the browser, it seems to be doing it’s job, I need to play a little more.

1 Like