7of9, this is actually wrong, check xprivacy lua. The question should not be “allow or it doesnt work” but rather “would you like to fake this information”. Android actually did it wrong here from google wish for a huge payoff, but based on GDPR:
EDPS Opinion 4/2017 on the Proposal for a Directive on certain aspects concerning contracts for the supply of digital content, 14 March 2017, p. 7.
“There might well be a market for personal data, just like there is, tragically, a market for live human organs, but that does not mean that we can or should give the market the blessing of legislation. One cannot monetize and subject a fundamental right to a simple commercial transaction, even if it is the individual concerned by the data who is a party to the transaction.”
Bottom line. If the application requires some data that don’t need to be given based on what it needs to perform its functionality, it is in direct violation of GDPR and it would be really helpful if Sailfish would help here by faking the results, preventing application from breaking and on the other side protecting the owner of the phone. If the information is really needed (like GPS coordinates for some map), the user will allow it.
On the other side, if text editor will require GPS coordinates, than any coordinates are just fine - it doesnt need them.
I am for last 10 years living on Christmas Islands for any application that wants to know my location - but this is me. I can fight back with technical measures but most users cant.
Anyway, I think that there is a great opportunity for sailfish today. People are slowly realizing what privacy means and how badly they were treated from google, fb, … Here is a sweet spot for a huge business, but supporting 2 year+ old phones will not get it there.
Start bonding.