Apps/services to sync calendar and contacts ("PIM")

My Jolla Phone 2 is in the mail. I wonder what service to use for syncing contacts and calendar.

For (almost) as long as I can remember, I have synced with my job Exchange account on my primary mobile phone. This has been across onprem Exchange and then 365, across old Symbian Nokias with third party app, Windows Mobile 5 and 6 (e.g. HTC TyTN II), N900 (Maemo 5, still have it), Jolla Phone (still have it) and then on various Androids (no Samsung). On Android using first builtin mail/calender/sync, and in last few years Outlook on Android. I had a single contact database and calendar “in Outlook” and on my phone.

Now with the JP2 on the way, this method is over: The company I work for now, have quite strict “compliance” demands, on Android demanding “compliant phone” with “company portal” and “work profile” and MS Defender. Sailfish is surely no go. I just presume this is not possible on Sailfish. So for the first time in almost 25 years I will have to be split-brained. Separate work calendar (and contacts) vs. personal.

The easy way out is used by many colleagues who want to be split-brained: They use Google services privately and have “private” contacts and calendar on their Android phone. But I want to break free from Google.

For my private e-mail I already use Proton, with Thunderbird as client. But I presume Proton contacts and calendar do not sync to Sailfish native contacts/calendar, just it’s own app. Also with Proton I must use their own Android app. I would be willing to switch to a different e-mail service, even not as privacy focused, if I could sync to native contacts/calendar. My e-mail is on a domain I own, so I could move it.

Basically what I am after: If I store or update a contact on my desktop e-mail app, it syncs to the phone’s native contact database. And vice versa, if I change or update a contact on the phone, it syncs to the desktop mail app. And also same idea for calendar. A reasonable cost even up to, say $100/year is OK. I see alternatives to Proton that support CalDAV and CardDAV, which I presume could work, but I am hoping to hear about actual real-world experience on SailfishOS.

On the desktop the client could be Outlook, Thunderbird or a web client. As a possible way out I could even pay for a separate MS 365 subscription - I can manage that on my own, on my personal company, and I would rather bow to MS here, than to Google, if that’s what it takes (and Sailfish’s client still works with modern 365 and OAUTH, which seems dubious). I would be able to self-host, but I’m not interested in spending the time - I would rather pay.

I have found this thread, which is relevant, has tips and is not too old. mailbox.org seems maybe to fit the bill.

And a topic suggestion for a yet upcoming IRC community meeting.

But I come here asking is anyone has any other suggestions and hands-on experiences.

Don’t go with MS/Outlook, I believe they don’t have proper IMAP support so the only way to use it is with the Outlook app for Android.

Other than that, any mail hosting provider that supports the standard protocols (IMAP, CalDAV, CardDAV) should work. I’ll add a +1 positive review for Mailbox.org, have been using them for a few years with my own domain name for emails. Mail, contacts (multiple address books) calendar (multiple calendars) all sync properly to my Jolla after setting up the accounts. Also works like a charm on desktop with Evolution and I suspect Thunderbird too.

With MS 365, I wouldn’t use IMAP, but their proprietary protocol if Sailfish still supports it. (I’m unsure.) The MS 365 suite does have it’s strengths, even though I do not think it has many fans in here…

While it’s maybe not the most freedom- or privacy-respecting version, I have been using MemoToo for years now (mainly for contacts, but in the past also for calendars and mail).
They have native SFOS integration, and even if that failes, they support basically every synchronisation method there ever was, from SyncML to Exchange, DAV, csv, you name it.

That means whatever data I have on there I can sync with whatever ancient device, on whatever operating system, or use some selfmade scripts or whatever.
(So yes I can today create a contact on my JP26, and tomorrow that contact will be available on my J1 and N9. If I still had my Zaurus, I could probably syncML it there too. And with khal and khard also available on any Linux machine I can ssh into.).

For me that’s a huge plus.

Nextcloud is always a good option of you want to self-host or rent a hosted instance. It’s not PIM-focused but their interfaces work reasonably well.

I use Fastmail mainly because Proton was lacking support for any sensible standard and their Bridge app is more of a workaround than a proper solution. Also Fastmail is a main contributor to the JMAP prorocol, so while they acknowledge the limitations of IMAP they went with developing a more modern and more secure, and most importantly open standard rather than making excuses not to do that like Proton.

Well, it was a pain to set it up on Sailfish but it’s working now. For reference on desktop setting up Fastmail on Thunderbird is a 2 click process as it supports Oauth properly but in Evolution I had to set up everything separately and manually, but at least it works there. On Kontact I have no idea how to setup my account, it’s straight up broken. So after all Sailfish is not the worst but not the best either.

FYI at the next community meeting I brought up this topic to discuss.

Thanks so far. MemoToo is interesting in its own right. I like the mission statement of “sync with everything and every protocol”. Also, I am impressed if you actually have an J1 and N9 running (I have J1s and N900 in the drawer. Some year(s) ago I tried to reset and update the J1, but SFOS got dead slow with newer versions. Both Fastmail and mailbox look OK so far. Fastmail oddly didn’t come up in the thread about the same topic i December/January.

Well, they are there, they work, battery is OK enough to turn them on once in a while (and I actually have a replacement battery stored for each somewhere). But I’m of course not really using them often.
The accounts are set up though.

Yeah, I saw. Maybe I’ll get back on IRC to be able to lurk.

Been using a small self-hosted Radicale server with Android for a few years, it is very easy to self-host and does not need to be always online.

I recently received my J26 in the mail, set up the CalDav/CardDav address and everything synced properly between Android, Jolla and Thunderbird/Gnome apps on desktop, no trouble.

The only thing missing so far on Jolla is VTODO (Tasks) CalDav sync support, for which I use an app from F-Droid.

I went with Fastmail as I am a longtime cyrus fan and user/admin 2000-2020. Mailbox.de has the better promise when it comes to data sovereignty and privacy. But Fastmail has a compelling feature set and UI. I even have a friend and cousin who is also attempting to go Jolla now. We share a Fastmail family and have both our custom domains. I had some serious challenges setting up calendar and contacts, as @usbee mentioned. I’ll do a write-up of the config later. (Famous last words.)

As it seems like you have to add CardDAV and CalDAV separately, use full url¹² and make sure you use an app specific password³ you created earlier at Fastmail.

¹https://caldav.fastmail.com/dav/principals/user/USER@DOMAIN.COM/ for calendar and

²https://carddav.fastmail.com/dav/principals/user/USER@DOMAIN.COM/ for contacts as two separated accounts.

³It’s on app.fastmail.com them settings then security. Keep in mind that you will see the app password once so it’s worth to keep that around at least during the setup process. It’s required because of the lack of Oauth support.

Small writeup of Fastmail config. Those URLs look fine, and will probably work in many cases. Currently I’m using

https://carddav.fastmail.com/dav/addressbooks/user/[account]/Default

and

https://caldav.fastmail.com/dav/calendars/user/[account]
or
https://caldav.fastmail.com/dav/principals/user/[account]

I had serious problems, and had Claude make some probing scripts, which revealed the following:

My first test-account was firstname.lastname@fastmail.com.
Then the path for address books just had to be
https://carddav.fastmail.com/dav/addressbooks/user/firstname_lastname@fastmail.com/Default/

In the address book URL only, the name part of the account, only the part before the @, had to replace . with _.

It’s possible that the service discovery with the .well-known is done in a wrong way by Sailfish carddav/caldav as opposed to Fastmail. Sailfish ran the discovery against https://carddav.fastmail.com/.well-known (according to logs) but it should be https://carddav.fastmail.com/.well-known/carddav and caldav (according to Fastmail docs.

If the discovery had worked, maybe that would have yielded the firstname_lastname with an underscore.

I think possibly (not fully tested) that it works whether you use /principals/ or /calendar/addressbooks/ in either URL, and whether or not you include /Default or a trailing slash.